Showing posts with label independent contractor. Show all posts
Showing posts with label independent contractor. Show all posts

Independent Contractor Rule Under Pennsylvania Unemployment Law

Unemployment Attorney Representing Only Employees With Offices in Paoli, King of Prussia, Plymouth Meeting, Exton, Radnor and Philadelphia

This Blog is based upon my experience in litigating independent contractor cases before many Unemployment Hearing Referees, and also upon knowledge I have accumulated over the years in briefing independent contractor issues to the Unemployment Compensation Board of Review.

NOTE:  If you have received a Questionnaire from the Service Center, you may, after you have read this Post, want to Click Here to jump to our Post on how to complete such a Questionnaire.  Tricky business, indeed.

Can I Get Unemployment If I Am an Independent Contractor in Pennsylvania?

One cannot get unemployment in Pennsylvania if one is an "independent contractor." This may be important in either of the following contexts: 1) you lose your “independent contractor” job and file for unemployment benefits (if you are found to be a true independent contractor you will be denied benefits); or, 2) you are presently getting unemployment benefits and earn money on a “part-time” basis as an “independent contractor” (in which case you will be disqualified from getting benefits due to your “self-employed” status).

NOTE:  The below analysis in general does not apply to people employed by temporary employment agencies on a 1099 basis.  Click Here for analysis of such situations.

I Signed a Contract Saying I am an Independent Contractor - Is That the End of the Story?

Many people who have contracts that say they are "independent contractors " are not independent contractors (labels do not control - if I call a donkey a racehorse, it is still a donkey).  Rather, there is a fact-based test that is applied to determine your employment status.

The mere fact that you have signed an agreement saying you are an independent contractor, or are paid wages via a 1099, does not automatically mean you are an independent contractor (i.e. self-employed). Rather, you will be deemed to be truly self-employed only if you are free from direction and control while performing your work AND if you in fact are regularly engaged in an independently established trade, occupation or business.

Click Here to read our extensive analysis of the distinction between independent contractors and employees, and what you can do if you have been "misclassified."

What Is the Fact-Based Test for Determining if I am an Independent Contractor Under PA Unemployment Law?

Pursuant to Section 4(l)(2)(B) of the unemployment law, you are an independent contractor if:

1. You are free from control or direction over the performance of the services involved.  That means that by and large your work is completely unsupervised.  No one tells you what to do, how to do it, when to do it, etc.  If you do your work from home, that is a strong indicator that you are an independent contractor (but it is not dispositive), and;

2. You are customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation, profession or business.    The things to look for?  Do you advertise?  Do you rent office space?  Have you incorporated?  Do you subcontract some of the work you get?  Do you work for more than one employer? 

So, even if you work free from direction and control (i.e. work at home without regular supervision) and are thus a "true" independent contractor, you may still be entitled to unemployment benefits if you do not operate an established business.

Who Decides if I am an Independent Contractor

The above 2 prong legal test is heavily fact-driven, and there are many nuances. The issue is initially decided by the Unemployment Service Center via a Notice of Determination.  If there is an appeal from an NOD, the issue is then decided by a Pennsylvania Unemployment Referee at an Unemployment Hearing. 

Unemployment Lawyer Serving Individuals in Locations Such as Springfield, Malvern, Reading, Norristown, Media, West Chester, Doylestown, Ambler, Phoenixville, Downingtown, Lansdale and Surrounding Areas

If you have an upcoming hearing before an Unemployment Referee in Reading, Springfield, Malvern, Norristown, Bristol or Philadelphia, you will want to seriously consider hiring counsel to assist you. There is a lot at stake, and the evidentiary and legal issues associated with an independent contractor case are often complex, indeed.

MORE QUESTIONS?

Want more information about unemployment law in Pennsylvania?

Click Here to review our answers to the most common FAQs concerning Pennsylvania Unemployment, check out our Website or call us at 610-647-5027.  We also have some YouTube Videos that explain some unemployment law issues as well (just click the YouTube Badge at the top of this page).

Best of luck, John A. Gallagher, Esquire.
You have read this article 1099 / consulting / independent contractor / John A. Gallagher / Labor / lawyer / Malvern / Media / philadelphia / referee / unemployment with the title independent contractor. You can bookmark this page URL https://clapclapclappp.blogspot.com/2010/09/independent-contractor-rule-under.html. Thanks!

Independent Contractor Law in Pennsylvania

Philadelphia Unemployment Lawyer With Offices in Montgomery County and Delaware County

At the Gallagher Law Group, we represent only individuals with workplace rights issues. Call 610-647-5027, e-mail me directly or send an e-mail inquiry via the "Fill Out My Form" box to the upper right of this page. We will respond promptly with an analysis of your situation, and discuss potential options going forward at no cost to you.

If you need a Highly Experienced Unemployment Lawyer in the Philadelphia area who represents only individuals, John A. Gallagher has 20 years of experience, and offices in Plymouth Meeting, King of Prussia, Paoli, Exton,Radnor and Philadelphia.

Visit http://www.johnagallagher.com/.

What is the definition of an Independent Contractor in Pennsylvania?

The most important factors are often 1) how are you paid, W-2 or 1099? If paid 1099, presumption is you are an Independent Contractor; 2) Is there a contract that says you are an Independent Contractor. This is also considered strong evidence that you are not an employee.

Once you get beyond those factors, the issues are whether you are free from control in performing your day tp day activities, whether you have an established work schedule, whether you are subject to discipline and control by the employer, whether you work for more than more than one "employer," etc.

See our YouTube on this issue and 6 other commonly asked unemployment questions in Pennsylvania. The questions we answer are as follows:

1.  What is Willful Misconduct in Pennsylvania? 

2.  If I Quit My Job, Am I Entitled to Pennsylvania Unemployment Benefits?

3.  May I Apply for Unemployment in Pennsylvania If I Am Getting Severance ?

4.  If I Am Disabled Can I Receive Pennsylvania Unemployment Benefits?

5.  Can I Receive Unemployment in Pennsylvania If I Work Part-Time and ?

6.  Am I Disqualified from Pennsylvania Unemployment If I Do Consulting Work?

7.  What is an Independent Contractor Under Pennsylvania Unemployment Law?


The Gallagher Law Group provides Independent Contractor guidance for individuals in communities such as Oley, North Coventry, Warwick, Parkerford, Spring City, Douglassville, Amity, Pottsgrove, Limerick, Oaks, Royersford and surrounding Montgomery County, Pennsylvania communities.


If you have a question about your independent contractor status in Pennsylvania, call us today and we will discuss your matter at no cost to you.
You have read this article 1099 / consulting / emergency unemployment / independent contractor / John Gallagher / Pennsylvania / W-2 / willful misconduct with the title independent contractor. You can bookmark this page URL https://clapclapclappp.blogspot.com/2010/08/independent-contractor-law-in.html. Thanks!

Can I Work Part-Time and Get Unemployment in Pennsylvania?

Philadelphia Unemployment Lawyer With Offices in Delaware County and Chester County

At the Gallagher Law Group, we represent only individuals with workplace rights issues. Call 610-647-5027, e-mail me directly or send an e-mail inquiry via the "Fill Out My Form" box to the upper right of this page. We will respond promptly with an analysis of your situation, and discuss potential options going forward at no cost to you.

If you need a Highly Experienced Unemployment Lawyer in the Philadelphia area who represents only individuals, John A. Gallagher has 20 years of experience, and offices in Plymouth Meeting, King of Prussia, Paoli, Exton,Radnor and Philadelphia.

Visit http://www.johnagallagher.com/.

The simple answer to this question is - there is not a simple answer.  Basically, if you are working on a w-2 basis and earn no more than 40% of your weekly unemployment benefit, you will not lose any unemployment benefits.  After that, you will suffer a reduction in benefits.  If you are working on a 1099 basis, an independent contractor basis, then you may well be disqualified from receiving benefits.

See our YouTube on this issue and 6 other commonly asked unemployment questions in Pennsylvania. The questions we answer are as follows:

1.  What is Willful Misconduct in Pennsylvania? 

2.  If I Quit My Job, Am I Entitled to Pennsylvania Unemployment Benefits?

3.  May I Apply for Unemployment in Pennsylvania If I Am Getting Severance ?

4.  If I Am Disabled Can I Receive Pennsylvania Unemployment Benefits?

5.  Can I Receive Unemployment in Pennsylvania If I Work Part-Time and ?

6.  Am I Disqualified from Pennsylvania Unemployment If I Do Consulting Work?

7.  What is an Independent Contractor Under Pennsylvania Unemployment Law?


The Gallagher Law Group handles Unemployment Compensation matters for individuals in communities such as Plymouth Whitemarsh, Chestnut Hill, Plymouth Meeting, Blue Bell, Chalfont, Springfield, Broomall, Newtown Square, Media, Norristown, Lansdale, Horsham, East Goshe, West Chester and Malvern.

If you have a question about unemployment in Pennsylvania, call us today and we will discuss your matter at no cost to you.
You have read this article 1099 / benefits / employment law / independent contractor / Law Firm / Pennsylvania / philadelphia / referee / Severence / unemployment compensation / W-2 with the title independent contractor. You can bookmark this page URL https://clapclapclappp.blogspot.com/2010/08/can-i-work-part-time-and-get.html. Thanks!

What the Heck is a Sideline Business Under Pennsylvania Unemployment Law, Anyway?

Philadelphia Unemployment Lawyer With Offices in Delaware County and Chester County

At the Gallagher Law Group, we represent only individuals with workplace rights issues. Call 610-647-5027, e-mail me directly or send an e-mail inquiry via the "Fill Out My Form" box to the upper right of this page. We will respond promptly with an analysis of your situation, and discuss potential options going forward at no cost to you.

If you need a Highly Experienced Unemployment Lawyer in the Philadelphia area who represents only individuals, John A. Gallagher has 20 years of experience, and offices in Plymouth Meeting, King of Prussia, Paoli, Exton,Radnor and Philadelphia.

Visit http://www.johnagallagher.com/.

HOW CAN HAVING A SIDELINE BUSINESS IN PENNSYLVANIA HELP ME?

If you are receiving unemployment benefits, and at the same time working as an independent contractor, you may be disqualified from receiving unemployment on the grounds that you are self employed.  If, however, you can prove that you have a Sideline Business, you will be deemed eligible to continue receiving unemployment in Pennsylvania.

WHAT IS THE DEFINITION OF SIDELINE EMPLOYMENT UNDER PENNSYLVANIA UNEMPLOYMENT LAW?

Click Here to examine a Pennsylvania case that provides the test for a sideline business.  In general, a Sideline Business is an enterprise that you have operated while you were employed on a full time basis, that you continue to operate after you become unemployed from full-time employment.  In such cases, you will remain eligible to continue receiving benefits provided that 1) the sideline business was never your primary source of income; 2) you continue to look for work; and, 3) you have not increased the amount of time spent operating the sideline business since you became unemployed.

Example:  Accountant employed by an accounting firm from time to time prepares and files tax returns on behalf of friends and family.  After she is fired, she provides the same services to her friends and family.  She is eligible to continue receiving benefits from unemployment. 

Note:  You should report to unemployment that you are doing the sideline work as soon as you start doing it (i.e. do not wait until you have been paid).  If the Service Center should discontinue benefits, appeal and seek a Hearing before an Unemployment Referee.

Click Here to see our answers to FAQs relating to Pa Unemployment law and procedure.

See our YouTube on this issue and 6 other commonly asked unemployment questions in Pennsylvania. The questions we answer are as follows:

1.  What is Willful Misconduct in Pennsylvania? 

2.  If I Quit My Job, Am I Entitled to Pennsylvania Unemployment Benefits?

3.  May I Apply for Unemployment in Pennsylvania If I Am Getting Severance ?

4.  If I Am Disabled Can I Receive Pennsylvania Unemployment Benefits?

5.  Can I Receive Unemployment in Pennsylvania If I Work Part-Time and ?

6.  Am I Disqualified from Pennsylvania Unemployment If I Do Consulting Work?

7.  What is an Independent Contractor Under Pennsylvania Unemployment Law?


The Gallagher Law Group handles Unemployment Compensation matters for individuals in communities such as Plymouth Whitemarsh, Chestnut Hill, Plymouth Meeting, Blue Bell, Chalfont, Springfield, Broomall, Newtown Square, Media, Norristown, Lansdale, Horsham, East Goshe, West Chester and Malvern.

If you have a question about unemployment in Pennsylvania, call us today and we will discuss your matter at no cost to you.
You have read this article appeal hearing / determination / employment law / independent contractor / John Gallagher / Montgomery County / part time employment / Sideline Business / West Chester with the title independent contractor. You can bookmark this page URL https://clapclapclappp.blogspot.com/2010/08/what-heck-is-sideline-business-under.html. Thanks!

I Am Being Classsified as an Independent Contractor and Am Being Denied Unemployment In Pennsylvania

Philadelphia Unemployment Lawyer With Offices in Delaware County and Chester County

At the Gallagher Law Group, we represent only individuals with workplace rights issues. Call 610-647-5027, e-mail me directly or send an e-mail inquiry via the "Fill Out My Form" box to the upper right of this page. We will respond promptly with an analysis of your situation, and discuss potential options going forward at no cost to you.

If you need a Highly Experienced Unemployment Lawyer in the Philadelphia area who represents only individuals, John A. Gallagher has 20 years of experience, and offices in Plymouth Meeting, King of Prussia, Paoli, Exton,Radnor and Philadelphia.

Visit http://www.johnagallagher.com/.

See our YouTube on this issue and 6 other commonly asked unemployment questions in Pennsylvania. The questions we answer are as follows:

1.  What is Willful Misconduct in Pennsylvania? 

2.  If I Quit My Job, Am I Entitled to Pennsylvania Unemployment Benefits?

3.  May I Apply for Unemployment in Pennsylvania If I Am Getting Severance ?

4.  If I Am Disabled Can I Receive Pennsylvania Unemployment Benefits?

5.  Can I Receive Unemployment in Pennsylvania If I Work Part-Time and ?

6.  Am I Disqualified from Pennsylvania Unemployment If I Do Consulting Work?

7.  What is an Independent Contractor Under Pennsylvania Unemployment Law?


The Gallagher Law Group handles Unemployment Compensation matters for individuals in communities such as Downingtown, Kennett Square, Chesterbrook, Wayne, Devon, Berwyn, Strafford, Villanova, Bryn Mawr, Armore, Haverford, Havertown, Wynnewood, Drexel Hill, Aston, Lansdale, Horsham and Chalfont.  If you have a question about unemployment in Pennsylvania, call us today and we will discuss your matter at no cost to you.
You have read this article 1099 / Attorney / Chester County / consultant / independent contractor / John A. Gallagher / labor law / part time employment / Pennsylvania / Severence / unemployment benefits / unemployment hearing with the title independent contractor. You can bookmark this page URL https://clapclapclappp.blogspot.com/2010/08/i-am-being-classsified-as-independent.html. Thanks!

If I Take a Part Time Job, Can I Get Pennsylvania Unemployment Compensation?

Philadelphia Unemployment Lawyer With Offices in Montgomery County and Delaware County

The short answer is: if you take a part-time job and are paid W-2 wages, you can earn up to 40% of your weekly unemployment benefit without suffering any loss of unemployment benefits.  YOU MUST NEVERTHELESS REPORT THESE WEEKLY EARNINGS TO UNEMPLOYMENT.

If, on the other hand, you take part-time work and are paid as an independent contractor (W-9 wages), you will in most cases be disqualified from receiving benefits if in fact you are an independent contractor.  However, the mere fact that you have a contract that says you are an independent contractor is not proof that you are an independent contractor (if I call a donkey a racehorse, it's still a donkey).  Also, if your self-employment is a sideline business, then you are still entitled to unemployment.

If you have a Hearing before an Unemployment Referee on the issue of whether you are an independent contractor, you are strongly advised to consider retaining counsel

At the Gallagher Law Group, we represent only individuals with workplace rights issues. Call 610-647-5027, e-mail me directly or send an e-mail inquiry via the "Fill Out My Form" box to the upper right of this page. We will respond promptly with an analysis of your situation, and discuss potential options going forward at no cost to you.

If you need a Highly Experienced Unemployment Lawyer in the Philadelphia area who represents only individuals, John A. Gallagher has 20 years of experience, and offices in Plymouth Meeting, King of Prussia, Paoli, Exton,Radnor and Philadelphia.

Visit http://www.johnagallagher.com/.


See our YouTube on this issue and 6 other commonly asked unemployment questions in Pennsylvania.
The questions we answer are as follows:

1.  What is Willful Misconduct in Pennsylvania? 

2.  If I Quit My Job, Can I Get Unemployment in Pennsylvania?

3.  If I Am Getting Severance, May I Apply for Unemployment in Pennsylvania?

4.  Can I Draw Pennsylvania Unemployment Benefits If I Am Disabled?

5.  Can I Work Part-Time and Receive Unemployment in Pennsylvania?

6.  If I Do Consulting Work, Am I Disqualified from Pennsylvania Unemployment?

7.  What is an Independent Contractor In Pennsylvania for Purposes of Unemployment?
    The Gallagher Law Group handles Unemployment Appeal matters for individuals in communities Devon, Wynnewood, Malvern, Nether Providence, Chalfont, Horsham, Perkasie, West Norriton, Royersford, Oaks and Phoenixville.  If you have a question about unemployment in Pennsylvania, call us today and we will discuss your matter at no cost to you.
    You have read this article Attorney / benefits / consultant / independent contractor / John A. Gallagher / Labor / part time employment / Sideline Business / unemployment appeal / unemployment compensation with the title independent contractor. You can bookmark this page URL https://clapclapclappp.blogspot.com/2010/08/if-i-take-part-time-job-can-i-get.html. Thanks!